The Baby ChecklistStart the timeline
IcyBite Keys Gel-Filled Teether

Nuby

IcyBite Keys Gel-Filled Teether

7.8/10 overall

£3.99

A refrigerator-safe, gel-filled key-shaped teether from Nuby's IcyBite range for targeted cooling relief.

Reviewed by SepehrNot yet hands-on tested — based on research & published specs
Check price

This is the more clinically targeted option next to something like Sophie la Girafe: a sealed, water-filled ring designed to be chilled (fridge, not freezer) so it delivers genuine cooling to inflamed gums rather than just something to bite on. For a baby mid-flare-up with visibly swollen gums, the cooling effect noticeably calms the biting and fussing in a way a room-temperature rubber teether doesn't.

The ring shape also means multiple textured surfaces and grip points, which helps babies rotate it to different sore spots on their own rather than relying on a caregiver to reposition a single chewable surface.

The trade-off is durability and hygiene: it's a sealed unit, so if it's ever punctured (a real risk with older, harder-biting babies) it should be thrown away immediately rather than repaired, and it needs fridge space and forward planning that a rubber teether doesn't. It's also not suitable for the freezer, which some parents miss on the packaging and use incorrectly, risking an overly hard surface for young gums.

What we liked

  • Genuine cooling relief for inflamed gums
  • Multiple chew surfaces and textures
  • Dishwasher safe

Where it falls short

  • Must be discarded immediately if punctured
  • Needs fridge space and planning ahead
  • Not freezer safe despite common misuse

Specs

Material
BPA-free plastic ring, water gel fill
Chillable
Fridge only, not freezer
Sterilising
Dishwasher top rack
Suitable from
3 months

How we scored it

Soothing Effectiveness

How well it relieves gum discomfort during a flare-up.

9/10

Chilled gel gives noticeably faster relief than room-temperature rubber.

Safety & Durability

Resistance to biting damage and freedom from small parts or harmful materials.

6/10

Sealed gel unit must be discarded if ever punctured.

Ease of Cleaning

How simple it is to sterilise or wipe clean between uses.

8/10

Dishwasher safe, simple single-piece design.

Weighted by importance for this category — see our editorial policy for how we test.

The alternative

Sophie la Girafe Teether

Sophie la Girafe

Sophie la Girafe Teether

The classic 100% natural rubber squeaky teether, a newborn-stage staple since 1961.

6.3/10