
Matchstick Monkey
Original Teether
7.5/10 overall£10.99
A monkey-shaped silicone teether with a textured handle that doubles as a gum-massaging gel applicator.
Matchstick Monkey's Original Teether is a food-grade silicone toy shaped like a monkey with a long, textured tail/handle, designed so a caregiver can hold the "body" end and use the textured tip to massage a baby's gums directly — including the back molars that are hardest to reach with a toy a baby just chews on its own. It also doubles as a teething-gel applicator, since the bumpy silicone tip can carry and work gel (such as Dentinox) into the gum line rather than relying on a fingertip or cotton bud.
Compared with Sophie la Girafe, which is a squeaky natural-rubber toy babies mostly self-direct, the Matchstick Monkey is more of a two-person tool in its first months of use — a parent guides it — before it becomes a self-held chew toy as grip develops. That's a different use case to the Nuby mitten, which is worn on the baby's own hand for fully independent, unsupervised gnawing, or the Nuby Ice Gel Teether Ring, which relies on cold-filled gel for numbing relief rather than texture and massage. The silicone is plain (not gel- or water-filled), so there's nothing to leak or puncture, and Matchstick Monkey's marketing highlights an antimicrobial surface treatment (Biocote), though independent verification of any added hygiene benefit over normal cleaning is limited.
At around £10-£11 it sits above Sophie la Girafe and the Nuby options in price, and it lacks the fridge/freezer cooling relief that keys-style gel teethers (like the Nuby ring) provide — some parents find plain silicone alone less effective for the sharpest teething pain without that chilled numbing effect. It's dishwasher-safe and can be sterilised by steam, cold water or microwave, which is more convenient than the Sophie la Girafe rubber toy (hand-wash only, no steriliser or dishwasher). Overall this is best suited to parents who want a toy they can actively use to relieve a specific sore spot, or apply gel with, rather than one purely for independent chewing.
What we liked
- Textured tip works as a gum massager and gel applicator, reaching back molars
- Dishwasher and steriliser safe (steam, cold water, microwave) unlike the rubber Sophie la Girafe
- Firm one-piece silicone with no fill to leak or puncture
- Ergonomic handle suits both parent-guided use and independent grip as baby grows
Where it falls short
- Pricier than Sophie la Girafe and the Nuby teething products in this category
- No cooling/gel-filled relief — less numbing effect than fridge-chilled options for sharper pain
- Best "massaging" benefit needs an adult holding it, less purely independent than a wearable mitten
Specs
- Shape
- Monkey-shaped with textured handle/tail
- Cleaning
- Dishwasher safe; steam, cold water or microwave sterilisable
- Material
- Food-grade silicone, BPA-free
- Recommended use
- Gum massage, gel application, and independent chewing
- Available colours
- 18+ colourways
- Antimicrobial treatment
- Biocote-treated surface (manufacturer claim)
How we scored it
Soothing Effectiveness
How well it relieves gum discomfort during a flare-up.
Effective for targeted gum massage and gel application, but lacks the cooling numbing effect of the Nuby gel-filled ring, so less effective for acute teething pain on its own.
Safety & Durability
Resistance to biting damage and freedom from small parts or harmful materials.
Ease of Cleaning
How simple it is to sterilise or wipe clean between uses.
Dishwasher and steriliser safe across multiple methods, notably easier to keep hygienic than the hand-wash-only Sophie la Girafe rubber teether.
Weighted by importance for this category — see our editorial policy for how we test.
The alternative

Sophie la Girafe
Sophie la Girafe Teether
The classic 100% natural rubber squeaky teether, a newborn-stage staple since 1961.